英文论文审稿意见汇总
考驾照新规定-
英文论文审稿意见汇总
2011-04-24
19:24
以
下
12
点
无
轻
重
主
次
之
分
。
每
一
点
内<
/p>
容
由
总
结
性
标
题
和
代
表
性
审
稿
人
意
见
构
成
。
1
、
目
标
和<
/p>
结
果
不
清
晰
。
It
is
noted that
your m
anus
cript
needs
careful editing by
s
om
eone with expertise in
technical Englis
h editing
paying particular attention to Englis
h
gramm
ar, spelling, and
s
entence
s
tructure s
o that the
goals
and results
of the
s
tudy are clear to the
reader.
2
、
未
解
释
研
究
方
法
或
解
释
不
充
分<
/p>
。
◆
In general, there is
a lack
of explanation of replicates
and
s
tatis
tical me
thods
us
ed in the
s
tudy.
◆
Furthermore, an
explanation of why the authors
did
these various
experim
ents
s
hould be provided.
< br>3
、
对
于
研
究
设
计
的
rationale:
Als
o, there are few
explanations
of the rationale for the
s
tudy des
ign.
4
、
夸
张
地
陈
述
结
论
/
夸
大
成
果
/
不
严
谨
:
The conclus
ions
are overs
tated.
For
exam
ple, the s
tudy did not
s
how
if the
s
ide effects
from
initial copper burs
t can be avoid with
the polym
er form
ulation.
5
、
对
hypoth
es
is
的
清
晰
界
定
:
A
h
ypothesis
needs
to be pres
ented
。
6
、
对
某
p>
个
概
念
或
工
具
使
用
的
rationale/
定
义
概
念
:
What was
the
rationale for the film
/SBF
volum
e ratio?
7
、<
/p>
对
研
究
问
题
的
定
义
:
Tr
y
to
s
et the problem
dis
c
uss
ed in
this
paper in m
ore clear,
write one section to
define the problem
8
< br>、
如
何
凸
现
原
创
性
以
及
如
何
充
p>
分
地
写
liter
ature review:
The
topic
is
novel
but
the
application
propos
ed
is
not
so
novel.
9
、
对
claim
,
如
A
>
B
的
证
明
,
verification:
There
is
no experim
ental
com
paris
on of the
algorithm
with previous
ly
known work, s
o it
is
imposs
ible to
judge whether the algorithm
is
an im
provem
ent
on previous
work.
10
< br>、
严
谨
度
问
题
:
MNQ is
eas
ier
than the prim
itive PNQS, how to prove
that.
11
、
< br>格
式
(
重
视
程
度
)
:
◆
In
addition, the lis
t of
refere
nces
is
not
in our s
tyle. It is
close
but not com
pletely
correct.
I have at
tached a pdf file with
tructions
for
Authors
exam
ples.
◆
Before
subm
itting a revis
ion be
s
ure that your m
aterial
is
properly prepared and
form
atted.
If
you are uns
ure, pleas
e
cons
ult the form
atting
ns
tructions
to
authors
that are
given under
the
tructions
and
Forms
-hand corner of the
s
creen.
12
、
语
言
问
题
(
出
现
最
多
的
问
题<
/p>
)
:
有
关
语
言
的
审
稿
人
意
见
:
◆
It
is
noted that your
m
anus
cript needs
careful editing by
s
om
eon
e with
expertis
e in
technical
Englis
h editing paying particular
attention to Englis
h
gramm
ar, spelling, and
s
entence
s
tructure s
o that the
goals
and results
of the
s
tudy are clear to the
reader.
◆
The authors
m
us
t have their work
reviewed by a proper
trans
lation/reviewing service
before
s
ubmiss
ion; only then can a
proper review be perform
ed.
Mos
t s
entences
contain
gramm
atical and/or
s
pelling
m
is
takes
or are
not com
plete sentences.
◆
As
presented, the writing is
not
acceptable for the journal.
There are pro
blems
with
s
entence s
tructure, verb
tens
e, and clause
cons
truction.
◆
The English of
your m
anus
cript
m
us
t be improved before
resubm
ission. We
s
tr
ongly
s
ugges
t that you obtain
ass
is
tance from
a
colleague who is
well
-vers
ed i
n
English or whose native lang
uage
is
English.
◆
Pleas
e have
s
om
eone com
petent
in the Englis
h language and the
s
ubject matte
r
of
your paper go over the paper and
correct it. ?
◆
the quality of Englis
h
needs
im
proving.
来
自
编
辑
的<
/p>
鼓
励
:
Encouragem
ent
from
reviewers
:
◆
I would be very
glad to re
-review the paper in greater
depth once it has
be
en
edited becaus
e the subject
is
interes
ting.
◆
There
is
continued interes
t in
your m
anus
cript titled
itted to the Journal of
Biom
edical Materials
Res
earch: Part B
-
Applied Biom
at
erials.
◆
The Subm
iss
ion
has
been greatly im
proved
and is
worthy of publication.
本
文
来
自
CSDN
博
客
,
转
载
请
标
明
出
处
:
htt
p
://b
/chenyus
iyua
n/a
rchive
< br>/2008/12/03/
p
x
老
外
写
的
p>
英
文
综
述
文
章
的
审
稿
意
见
Ms. Ref. No.: ******
Title:
******
Materials
Science and Engineering
Dear Dr. ******,
Reviewers
have now commented
on your p